Royce Da 5’9” has never been a stranger to self-expression. He famously scoured the darkest depths his soul like Detroit’s Edgar Allan Poe on Death Is Certain. He penned his own autobiography sans filter on Book Of Ryan — Songs like “Tabernacle” and “Startercoat” are chapters a living breathing story. He shares and he draws his own conclusions. It’s been that way for over two decades now, rising from the sewer smoke and wreaking havoc on “Game Radio FM.”
It shouldn’t be surprising that Royce decided to soundtrack his eighth studio album. Even if it meant taking up a trade and effectively starting on a blank slate. Royce is undisputedly one the game’s lyrical elites; a one-percenter. In the production sphere he’s simply a dreamer looking to make an honest living. It serves to imbue his work with a charming sort DIY ruggedness. Many samples are flipped and some arrangements are more intricate than others. Royce sets himself up to deliver a rapper’s album, unpretentious and economical. His efforts shine brightest on the hypnotic “Thou Shall” and the heavily Primo-inspired “I Play Forever.” For better or worse it never feels like he’s overthinking. Even when questionable choices are made there’s comfort in knowing that the one making them is doing so on his own accord.
Agency is a major theme across The Allegory. The willingness to control one’s own destiny and retain artistic freedom. As he explains on “Rhinestone Doo Rag,” he wore one so younger artists “won’t have to.” There’s an aura triumph achieved through sacrifice, a process trial and error that molded an eager student into a wizened teacher. Royce doesn’t deal in didacticism; his lessons are ten left open to interpretation. Taking to a dissonant and feverish guitar loop on “Pendulum,” Royce fires f so many gems it’s impossible to unearth them all without repeat listens. Refreshingly embracing the comedic subgenre “dad-rap,” Royce’s playful sense humor never undercuts the impact his insight. “Now, I’m falling in a downward spiral, my main ho is ‘s side ho with “model” in the bio,” he laments. “I’m starting to sound dated, ‘Cause I ain’t paid attention to the climate since the Nae-Nae.”
As a craftsman, Royce’s confidence is at an all-time high. He’s proven time and again that his prowess is second to none. But The Allegory is not about putting on a masterclass in flow through select moments might suggest otherwise. “I Play Forever” is one them, in which Royce connects with fellow veteran for a pair murderous verses. “FUBU” is another, with Royce absolutely refusing to be outdone by Conway; no easy feat as doing so requires a Herculean performance. Despite these moments technical brilliance, The Allegory is more so about the message Royce is looking to convey — either to the listener or to himself. In the introductory “Mr. Grace,” Royce likens the album to Plato’s “Allegory Of The Cave,” hinting at the album’s conceptual narrative; in its simplest interpretation, the idea perception vs. reality. Perhaps Royce’s Allegory is not in itself an allegory to be unpacked, but rather a direct allusion to the ideas presented in Plato’s theory.
Through that lens, there are times where Royce knows exactly what lies behind the curtain. Or in keeping with Plato’s imagery, the tangible forms standing behind the row ignorant prisoners. When speaking on topics like the nefarious elements the record industry, Royce’s voice carries authority; there’s a reason he’s still thriving twenty-years down the line, the proud owner his own masters and publishing. It’s all too easy to imagine nameless suits standing behind a row young rappers making shadow puppets on the wall. Songs like “Tricked” and “Upside Down” find Royce seeking to expose the truth as he sees it. To unchain the proverbial prisoners and force them to address their status as pawns. The water darkens when he wades into topics on which his research process holds a confirmation bias. Much has been made anti-vaxx sentiments and perhaps not enough has been made about the circumstances that might have led to such an empirically disprovable conclusion. Though it does feel like The Allegory has been designed to convert those willing to see the light, it also speaks to the fallibility man on a variety levels — alas, not all them intentional.
This sort complexity is a quality that Royce himself has experienced first hand, chiefly explored through his relationship with his father on “Hero.” A force can be at once destructive and inspirational, wrong in the name righteousness. While The Allegory is not Royce’s best album, there’s a certain transcendental quality that cannot be denied. It’s certainly his most dense body work; bars fly overhead packed with hidden meaning and double entendres, don’t even ask him how. Whether his messages land will depend wholly on the listener’s willingness to respect the source. Those expecting Royce to concoct something en vogue or trendy will leave disappointed. He’s earned the right to stay within his comfort zone — but damned if he hasn’t been steadily renovating it over the years.